Tissue Trek Project Rubric
Portfolio and Video Assessment • 100 Points
Group members:
Create a research portfolio and a 10–20 minute video that demonstrate an accurate understanding of tissues and the Tissue Trek assignment. Rate each criterion from 1–5. Portfolio: 55%; video: 40%; group process: 5%.
Use the expectations in each row to assign a 1–5 rating. Add the ratings within each section, then use the formulas below to convert section totals to weighted points. Final grade: 100 points.
5 Excellent — Meets all expectations; accurate, complete, and clear.
4 Proficient — Meets most expectations; minor errors or omissions.
3 Developing — Meets some expectations; noticeable gaps or errors.
2 Limited — Meets few expectations; major gaps or errors.
1 Minimal — Very little relevant evidence; most expectations unmet.
Missing work: Record 0 only when no evidence is submitted for a criterion. Submitted work is rated from 1–5.
|
Criterion |
Expectations for a rating of 5 |
Rating |
|
1. Research participation |
Every member provides evidence of gathering relevant facts. |
____ / 5 |
|
2. Understanding the task |
Group demonstrates understanding of the project goals and requirements. |
____ / 5 |
|
3. Timely completion |
Group submits required assignments and final materials by the assigned deadlines. |
____ / 5 |
Group rating total: ______ / 15 Weighted score: (______ ÷ 15) × 5 = ______ / 5
|
Criterion |
Expectations for a rating of 5 |
Rating |
|
4. Research and evidence |
Includes relevant, accurate facts and at least three or more (3+) referenced sources per member; identifies each member’s contributions named. |
____ / 5 |
|
5. APA references |
Uses APA style for in-text citations and a reference list; credits borrowed facts and images. |
____ / 5 |
|
6. Supporting materials |
Includes scripts, outlines, pictures, and/or other materials that document planning and support the video. |
____ / 5 |
|
7. Organization |
Uses clearly labeled sections and/or outlined in folder; materials are complete, readable, and easy to locate. |
____ / 5 |
|
8. Reflection |
Explains what the group learned, challenges encountered, and/or how members contributed to the final project. |
____ / 5 |
Portfolio rating total: ______ / 25 Weighted score: (______ ÷ 25) × 55 = ______
/ 55
Apply the same 1–5 rating scale to each criterion below. Assess the submitted video and its accessible playback link or file.
|
Criterion |
Expectations for a rating of 5 |
Rating |
|
9. Planning and rehearsal |
Scenes flow logically; transitions, pacing, and/or preparation show that the production was managed and rehearsed. |
____ / 5 |
|
10. Language and professionalism |
Speech and grammar are clear; language, costumes, and/or content are appropriate for a school audience. |
____ / 5 |
|
11. Sound and lighting |
Voices are understandable; lighting makes characters, models, and key visuals easy to see. |
____ / 5 |
|
12. Models and manipulatives |
Uses models, props, and/or manipulatives effectively to represent tissues or explain biological ideas. |
____ / 5 |
|
13. Facts in the story |
Relevant scientific facts are clearly stated or demonstrated and are meaningfully connected to the storyline. |
____ / 5 |
|
14. Scientific accuracy |
Accurately identifies featured tissues and/or explains how their structures relate to their functions. |
____ / 5 |
|
15. Equal participation |
Every member appears on film for approximately equal time and makes a meaningful contribution. |
____ / 5 |
|
16. Required length |
The completed video runs 10–20 minutes. |
____ / 5 |
|
17. Safety and judgment |
Demonstrates safe behavior and/or sound judgment; avoids dangerous actions or demonstrations. |
____ / 5 |
|
18. Character survival |
No student character dies or is killed during the story. |
____ / 5 |
|
19. Creativity |
Uses original ideas, imagination, and/or engaging storytelling to strengthen the science presentation. |
____ / 5 |
|
20. Access and submission |
Provides the video in the required media format and/or platform; the teacher can open and play it without access problems. |
____ / 5 |
Video rating total: ______ / 60 Weighted score: (______ ÷ 60) × 40 = ______ / 40
Add weighted scores: Group ______ / 5 + Portfolio ______ / 55 + Video ______ / 40
TOTAL:
Tissue Trek Example Scoring
Completed
Grading Example • 100 Points
Sample group: Team Tissue Trek
Fictional example for teacher reference
This fictional example shows how to apply 1–5 ratings and
calculate a weighted grade. Portfolio: 55%; video: 40%; group process: 5%.
Judge actual work against the rubric expectations.
Ratings: 5 = Excellent; 4 = Proficient; 3 = Developing; 2 =
Limited; 1 = Minimal. Missing evidence = 0.
Group Process 5 Percent
|
Criterion |
Example
evidence and scoring reason |
Rating |
|
1. Research participation |
All members submit research notes that identify the facts
they gathered. |
5 / 5 |
|
2.
Understanding the task |
The
group understands the main task but needs one reminder about required
supporting materials. |
4 / 5 |
|
3. Timely completion |
All required materials are submitted on time. |
5 / 5 |
Group rating total: 14 / 15 Weighted score: (14 ÷ 15) × 5 = 4.67 / 5
Portfolio 55 Percent
|
Criterion |
Example
evidence and scoring reason |
Rating |
|
4. Research and evidence |
Each member provides at least three relevant sources;
facts are accurate and contributions are identified. |
5 / 5 |
|
5. APA
references |
Facts
and images are credited; the reference list has a few minor APA formatting
errors. |
4 / 5 |
|
6. Supporting materials |
The portfolio includes a complete script, outline, labeled
pictures, and planning materials. |
5 / 5 |
|
7.
Organization |
Sections
are clearly labeled; all materials are readable and easy to find. |
5 / 5 |
|
8. Reflection |
The reflection explains learning and member contributions
but gives little detail about resolving challenges. |
4 / 5 |
Portfolio rating total: 23 / 25 Weighted score: (23 ÷ 25) × 55 = 50.60 / 55
Video 40 Percent
The example video earns 53 of 60 rating points. The evidence
below explains each rating.
|
Criterion |
Example
evidence and scoring reason |
Rating |
|
9. Planning and rehearsal |
The video is rehearsed and organized; a few transitions
are abrupt. |
4 / 5 |
|
10.
Language and professionalism |
Language,
grammar, costumes, and content are appropriate and professional. |
5 / 5 |
|
11. Sound and lighting |
Several lines are difficult to hear, and one scene is too
dark to see the model clearly. |
3 / 5 |
|
12.
Models and manipulatives |
Models
clearly illustrate tissues and help explain biological ideas. |
5 / 5 |
|
13. Facts in the story |
Relevant facts support most scenes, but one scene has a
weak connection to the science. |
4 / 5 |
|
14.
Scientific accuracy |
Tissue
names and major functions are correct; one structure–function explanation has
a minor error. |
4 / 5 |
|
15. Equal participation |
All members contribute meaningfully; one member has
slightly less screen time. |
4 / 5 |
|
16.
Required length |
The
finished video runs 15 minutes, within the required 10–20
minute range. |
5 / 5 |
|
17. Safety and judgment |
The group uses props safely and demonstrates sound
judgment throughout. |
5 / 5 |
|
18.
Character survival |
All
student characters survive; no character is killed. |
5 / 5 |
|
19. Creativity |
The story has engaging, original ideas, although a few
scenes are predictable. |
4 / 5 |
|
20.
Access and submission |
The
submitted link opens and the full video plays without access problems. |
5 / 5 |
Video rating total: 53 / 60 Weighted score: (53 ÷ 60) × 40 = 35.33 / 40
Final Score
Add weighted scores: 4.67 + 50.60 + 35.33 = 90.60 points
FINAL GRADE: 90.6 /
100 = 90.6%