Tissue Trek Project Rubric

Portfolio and Video Assessment • 100 Points

Group members:  

Create a research portfolio and a 10–20 minute video that demonstrate an accurate understanding of tissues and the Tissue Trek assignment. Rate each criterion from 1–5. Portfolio: 55%; video: 40%; group process: 5%.

Rating Scale

Use the expectations in each row to assign a 1–5 rating. Add the ratings within each section, then use the formulas below to convert section totals to weighted points. Final grade: 100 points.

5 Excellent — Meets all expectations; accurate, complete, and clear.

4 Proficient — Meets most expectations; minor errors or omissions.

3 Developing — Meets some expectations; noticeable gaps or errors.

2 Limited — Meets few expectations; major gaps or errors.

1 Minimal — Very little relevant evidence; most expectations unmet.

Missing work: Record 0 only when no evidence is submitted for a criterion. Submitted work is rated from 1–5.

Group Process 5 Percent

Criterion

Expectations for a rating of 5

Rating

1. Research participation

Every member provides evidence of gathering relevant facts.

____ / 5

2. Understanding the task

Group demonstrates understanding of the project goals and requirements.

____ / 5

3. Timely completion

Group submits required assignments and final materials by the assigned deadlines.

____ / 5

 

Group rating total: ______ / 15    Weighted score: (______ ÷ 15) × 5 = ______ / 5

Portfolio 55 Percent

Criterion

Expectations for a rating of 5

Rating

4. Research and evidence

Includes relevant, accurate facts and at least three or more (3+) referenced sources per member; identifies each member’s contributions named.

____ / 5

5. APA references

Uses APA style for in-text citations and a reference list; credits borrowed facts and images.

____ / 5

6. Supporting materials

Includes scripts, outlines, pictures, and/or other materials that document planning and support the video.

____ / 5

7. Organization

Uses clearly labeled sections and/or outlined in folder; materials are complete, readable, and easy to locate.

____ / 5

8. Reflection

Explains what the group learned, challenges encountered, and/or how members contributed to the final project.

____ / 5

 

Portfolio rating total: ______ / 25    Weighted score: (______ ÷ 25) × 55 = ______ / 55

Video 40 Percent

Apply the same 1–5 rating scale to each criterion below. Assess the submitted video and its accessible playback link or file.

Criterion

Expectations for a rating of 5

Rating

9. Planning and rehearsal

Scenes flow logically; transitions, pacing, and/or preparation show that the production was managed and rehearsed.

____ / 5

10. Language and professionalism

Speech and grammar are clear; language, costumes, and/or content are appropriate for a school audience.

____ / 5

11. Sound and lighting

Voices are understandable; lighting makes characters, models, and key visuals easy to see.

____ / 5

12. Models and manipulatives

Uses models, props, and/or manipulatives effectively to represent tissues or explain biological ideas.

____ / 5

13. Facts in the story

Relevant scientific facts are clearly stated or demonstrated and are meaningfully connected to the storyline.

____ / 5

14. Scientific accuracy

Accurately identifies featured tissues and/or explains how their structures relate to their functions.

____ / 5

15. Equal participation

Every member appears on film for approximately equal time and makes a meaningful contribution.

____ / 5

16. Required length

The completed video runs 10–20 minutes.

____ / 5

17. Safety and judgment

Demonstrates safe behavior and/or sound judgment; avoids dangerous actions or demonstrations.

____ / 5

18. Character survival

No student character dies or is killed during the story.

____ / 5

19. Creativity

Uses original ideas, imagination, and/or engaging storytelling to strengthen the science presentation.

____ / 5

20. Access and submission

Provides the video in the required media format and/or platform; the teacher can open and play it without access problems.

____ / 5

 

Video rating total: ______ / 60    Weighted score: (______ ÷ 60) × 40 = ______ / 40

Final Score

 

Add weighted scores: Group ______ / 5 + Portfolio ______ / 55 + Video ______ / 40

 

TOTAL:  

 

 

 

Tissue Trek Example Scoring 

Completed Grading Example • 100 Points

Sample group: Team Tissue Trek

Fictional example for teacher reference

This fictional example shows how to apply 1–5 ratings and calculate a weighted grade. Portfolio: 55%; video: 40%; group process: 5%. Judge actual work against the rubric expectations.

Ratings: 5 = Excellent; 4 = Proficient; 3 = Developing; 2 = Limited; 1 = Minimal. Missing evidence = 0.

Group Process 5 Percent

Criterion

Example evidence and scoring reason

Rating

1. Research participation

All members submit research notes that identify the facts they gathered.

5 / 5

2. Understanding the task

The group understands the main task but needs one reminder about required supporting materials.

4 / 5

3. Timely completion

All required materials are submitted on time.

5 / 5

Group rating total: 14 / 15    Weighted score: (14 ÷ 15) × 5 = 4.67 / 5

Portfolio 55 Percent

Criterion

Example evidence and scoring reason

Rating

4. Research and evidence

Each member provides at least three relevant sources; facts are accurate and contributions are identified.

5 / 5

5. APA references

Facts and images are credited; the reference list has a few minor APA formatting errors.

4 / 5

6. Supporting materials

The portfolio includes a complete script, outline, labeled pictures, and planning materials.

5 / 5

7. Organization

Sections are clearly labeled; all materials are readable and easy to find.

5 / 5

8. Reflection

The reflection explains learning and member contributions but gives little detail about resolving challenges.

4 / 5

Portfolio rating total: 23 / 25    Weighted score: (23 ÷ 25) × 55 = 50.60 / 55


 

Video 40 Percent

The example video earns 53 of 60 rating points. The evidence below explains each rating.

Criterion

Example evidence and scoring reason

Rating

9. Planning and rehearsal

The video is rehearsed and organized; a few transitions are abrupt.

4 / 5

10. Language and professionalism

Language, grammar, costumes, and content are appropriate and professional.

5 / 5

11. Sound and lighting

Several lines are difficult to hear, and one scene is too dark to see the model clearly.

3 / 5

12. Models and manipulatives

Models clearly illustrate tissues and help explain biological ideas.

5 / 5

13. Facts in the story

Relevant facts support most scenes, but one scene has a weak connection to the science.

4 / 5

14. Scientific accuracy

Tissue names and major functions are correct; one structure–function explanation has a minor error.

4 / 5

15. Equal participation

All members contribute meaningfully; one member has slightly less screen time.

4 / 5

16. Required length

The finished video runs 15 minutes, within the required 10–20 minute range.

5 / 5

17. Safety and judgment

The group uses props safely and demonstrates sound judgment throughout.

5 / 5

18. Character survival

All student characters survive; no character is killed.

5 / 5

19. Creativity

The story has engaging, original ideas, although a few scenes are predictable.

4 / 5

20. Access and submission

The submitted link opens and the full video plays without access problems.

5 / 5

Video rating total: 53 / 60    Weighted score: (53 ÷ 60) × 40 = 35.33 / 40

Final Score

Add weighted scores: 4.67 + 50.60 + 35.33 = 90.60 points

FINAL GRADE: 90.6 / 100 = 90.6%